Slack Connect: working with channels between organizations

With Slack Connect, channels connect you to people working at other companies and organizations. You can talk to them without leaving Slack—or your Slack apps—behind.

While many apps, bots, and other integrations should continue to work with channels that have members from multiple workspaces and organizations, you may face unexpected quirks. The Conversation APIs manages most of the complexity for you.

• What is Slack Connect?
• Designing your app to support Slack Connect
• How channels between organizations work
• Technical considerations: supporting Slack Connect
• Design considerations
• Behavior to expect
  • Beware sharing users' data
  • Slash commands are not shared
  • App unfurls may surprise you
  • Not all workspaces support Slack Connect
  • More than one workspace may be connected
  • You may have multiple bot copies
  • Beware of changing IDs on channels when a share is initiated
  • Beware of frozen and disconnected channels
  • There's currently no way to find all channels shared with a specific external organization
  • Beware of is_shared
  • Determining whether a user is external must be done implicitly
• Shared channels by API
• Requesting a sandbox
• Troubleshooting and known issues

What is Slack Connect?

A channel is a bridge between teams that need to work together. Teams use Slack Connect to communicate between workspaces, and organizations. Slack Connect allows users of different organizations to chat, share files, and use apps with the same cozy ease that they use to communicate with their more immediate colleagues in their workspace.

How channels between organizations work

Messages and files

All workspaces involved in a connected channel can read and send messages, share files, and access the history of shared channels.

Channel settings

A channel between workspaces or organizations may have different settings on each workspace it's party to.

• Channel names may differ. What's one workspace's #do-stuff is another workspace's #do-nothing. It's best to make no assumptions about channel names and stick only with IDs.
• One workspace might set the channel as private, while the other workspace may set the same channel as public.
• Data retention settings may differ between teams.

With all these differences in channel type settings, you must use the new Conversations API instead of existing APIs like channels.*, ims.*`, and groups.*

Technical considerations: supporting Slack Connect

Be on the lookout for minor differences in channel, message, user, team and related objects. When a channel can hold multiple teams within it, naturally you'll encounter messages and users originating from other teams.

🆕 Detecting when a channel has members from multiple workspaces or organizations

Your app can learn when channels become shared and unshared with another team by subscribing to the channel_shared and channel_unshared events in the Event Subscriptions tab under your Apps page.

To receive all shared events for channels or groups in a workspace, your app will need the channels:read or groups:read scope respectively. To receive only shared events for channels and groups your bot user is in, your app just needs the bot scope.

Both shared events contain the ID of the channel itself in addition to the team that the channel was shared or unshared with:

{
    "type": "channel_shared",
    "connected_team_id": "TLL6DGUHX",
    "channel": "CLZT0MJHZ",
    "event_ts": "1565722340.000000"
}

It may be helpful for your app to note the connected_team_id, as it will start receiving messages and events from users on that external team.

Users may seem strange

Your app will begin to receive messages and events from users on external teams. Information about these users will be different than users on the workspace where your app is installed.

An external member. In their profile, a member from an external team will be marked with a square status indicator next to the user name.

• External members are members on the other team that your application shares channel membership with.
• Strangers are external members on the other team that your application does not have a shared channel in common; you can find out about these members when the other team mentions them in the shared channel or shares one of their messages or files into the shared channel.

The user type object (returned by methods like users.info) provides additional information to identify external members, while withholding some information your app may expect.

• If the user is a stranger who isn't in any shared channels, the is_stranger flag is set true.
• For external members and strangers, profile data will not contain email even if you have the users:read.email scope.
• For external members and strangers, profile data will not contain any locale information, even if you pass the include_locale flag.

Here's an example of a response from users.info:

{
    "ok": true,
    "user": {
        "id": "U0BNRNDKJ",
        "team_id": "T07QCRP7S",
        "name": "rex",
        "real_name": "Devon Rex",
        "profile": {
            "image_24": "https:\/\/.../11662770033.jpg",
            "team": "T07QCRP7S",
            "display_name": "eshellstrop"
            // all that other stuff
        },
        "is_stranger": true
    }
}

Please note that when you specify a user, you need to use user id, instead of the username. With the new name-tagging feature, the username attribute cannot be relied on as a unique identifier, and will not work with "foreign" users via the API. For example, you cannot use chat.postMessage with a username set to a foreign user.

A bot user 🤖 is able to DM users on all connected workspaces, as long as users are in a shared channel together.

Same channel, different setting

When a channel gains members from another workspace or organization via Slack Connect, the channel ID rmay change, depending on its setting.

If the channel is set to private, the ID prefix may change from G to C (e.g. G1234567890 becomes C1234567890) when it's shared. Subscribe to the channel_id_changed event to determine when a private channel's ID has changed because a share has been initiated.

Since each team in the channel can independently decide if the channel is public or private on their end, so there are some changes with the APIs too:

• The conversations.* methods accept any type of channel.

• The channel type object now includes the channel type info (public, private, etc.).

• The conversations.info method will provide additional information on the workspaces connected to the shared channel and the ID of the host workspace.

The channel type object (which is returned by methods like conversations.info) tells you additional channel info. If the channel is shared externally (i.e., not just between multiple workspaces in your Grid organization), is_ext_shared is set to true. If it is a private channel or a group DM channel, the properties, is_private or is_mpim is set true, respectively.

Use the is_ext_shared, <is_private, and is_mpim flags exclusively to determine the privacy and type of a given channel. Beware of is_shared, which also includes channels shared between multiple workspaces in the same organization.

Example response from conversations.list:

{
    "ok": true,
    "channels": [
        {
            "id": "C0A1NBPT3",
            "name": "product-qa",
            "is_channel": true,
            "created": 1491332036,
            "creator": "U0A379ZT2",
            "is_archived": false,
            "is_general": false,
            "is_shared": true,
            "is_ext_shared": true,
            "is_org_shared": false,
            "is_member": false,
            "is_private": true,
            "is_mpim": false,
            "members": [
                "U0A379ZT2",
                "U0AU7DMHN"
            ],
             ...
        },
        { ...  },
    ]
}

Channels between organizations that are converted back to a single-organization channel

When a channel between organizations or workspaces is unshared by the host workspace, each workspace can still access channel history for all previous messages and activity. However, the channel in the disconnected workspace will be assigned a new ID, while the host workspace keeps the original channel ID.

Private channels between organizations

Channels between organizations and workspaces can be made private on a per-workspace basis. For instance, a public channel on one workspace can be shared with a private channel on another workspace. Use the Conversations API methods to work with the channels and accurately determine their privacy.

When a workspace's private shared channel becomes unshared, its channel ID remains C-prefixed (i.e. C1234567890 does not change back to G1234567890) although the channel is still private, making channel prefix an unreliable narrator in detesrmining privacy.

Design considerations

The most important technical requirement for supporting Slack Connect is that you must use the Conversations API to properly interact with channels that have been shared.

Next, we'll talk about design considerations for your app as it supports Slack Connect. Here's a quick set of questions to ask about your app before you consider it compatible with Slack Connect:

1. Does your app provide access to sensitive, internal data?

• You must ask for confirmation before sharing the info to an external partner.

2. Does your app have a slash command, shortcut, or message action?

• Be prepared to share an explanatory message saying this action can only be invoked by users from the workspace that installed the app,

3. Does your app have interactive elements?

• Consider who should be able to interact with those elements (like buttons and dropdown menus). Check the team_id of the originating user to be sure that they're part of the installing authorization.

If your app doesn't behave as expected, especially if it shares sensitive data to external parties, you may lose user trust, and you'll likely have your app uninstalled. Test your app thoroughly before you say that it's compatible with Slack Connect.

Behavior to expect

If your app is installed on one workspace, which shares a channel with a second external workspace, the users in the other workspace have not authorized your app. Or, conversely, you may have two installations of your app if the other workspace has also installed it. You'll have to design for both of these sorts of scenarios and expect the following behaviors:

Beware sharing users' data

As a rule of thumb, your app should default to exposing less information in shared channels to protect your users' data.

Bot users are accessible to all users on the workspace where your app is installed, and any external members in a channel between organizations where your bot is also present.

When an external member messages you, the team parameter will inform your app which team the message originated from. You can compare this to the team_id parameter, which indicates the workspace where the app is installed.

If your app typically shares sensitive information, make sure to change its behavior for external members.

Slash commands are not shared

Slash commands and message actions are not shared — they are limited only to the team that has installed to their team workspace. Another team needs to install them independently to be able to use them.

When your app is initiated by a slash command or message action, only the team that installed your app can invoke it, but external members can still see any information posted into channel as a result. For example, let's say Catnip inc. has installed a polling app that is initiated with a command /poll. Users in the Catnip inc. can initiate a poll, while Woof inc. can only vote on the poll and cannot create a new poll.

App unfurls may surprise you

link_shared events are not delivered when an external member shares a link that matches your app's unfurling domain, unless the app is installed in their workspace.

Not all workspaces support Slack Connect

Slack Connect channels are not available to all free workspaces. If your app builds with the assumption that a workspace or organization uses Slack Connect, it may not be available to all end users and workspaces.

More than one workspace may be connected

Slack Connect channels can connect up to 20 workspaces. Your app may choose to behave differently, or provide differing use cases, when there are two connected orgs or 10 connected orgs.

You may have multiple bot copies

If your app is installed on multiple workspaces that share a Slack Connect channel, you may have multiple app homes and multiple bot copies. Right now, we don't distinguish that a given app “belongs” to a particular workspace.

Beware of changing IDs on channels when a share is initiated

The moment a channel share is initiated, G-encoded private channels will have their ID immediately changed to be C-encoded—even if the channel is never successfully shared with an external org.

You'll want to subscribe to the new channel_id_changed event, which marks when a private channel's ID has changed because it has been shared:

    "event": {
      "type": "channel_id_changed",
      "old_channel_id": "G012Y48650T",
      "new_channel_id": "C012Y48650T",
      "event_ts": "1612206778.000000"
    }

Beware of frozen and disconnected channels

A conversation can be archived and frozen when an organization is disconnected from another with Slack Connect.

You may see a "frozen_reason": "connection_severed" in a Conversation object returned from the Conversations API.

The ID of a disconnected channel will change if your organization was invited to share it—i.e., your organization is not the host.

The host organization retains the original channel and original ID, while the invited organization get a copy of the channel that is assigned a new ID.

Your app will receive a channel_not_found error if you try to query the API with the original channel ID.

There's currently no way to find all channels shared with a specific external organization

Unfortunately, the conversations.list method does not include connected_team_ids.

Beware of is_shared

The property is_shared on a conversation object means the channel is shared with one or more workspaces. But beware: these can be internal workspaces (as with multi-workspace channels in Enterprise Grid) or external workspaces (as with Slack Connect).

Look for is_ext_shared and is_org_shared to learn which kind of shared channel you're viewing.

Determining whether a user is external must be done implicitly

Look for the is_stranger field in user objects. If it's true, you app does not share a channel with the user. If it's false, but the team associated with the user is not the installing team for your app, the user is external and your app does share a channel with them.

In other words, there is no single property to substantiate if the user is external or not: you must deduce it from a combination of the is_stranger and the team_id property.

Support strategies by feature

API	Support strategies
Events API	Support events originated from external users in the shared channels. No duplicated event triggering between shared channels To see which teams the event is delivered, look for the values of the authed_teams property for the response.
Web API	Support external users in shared channels. Some user-related actions will not be permissible due to their external nature Use users.info to retrieve additional information on cross-team user ID not found in users.list.
Incoming webhooks	Messages from incoming webhooks are visible to all members of a shared channel. Incoming webhook can send DM only to the users on installed teams.
Slash commands	Slash commands can be only invoked by users belonging to the workspace your app is installed. Turn on entity resolution for mentioned users, allowing you to identity them by id, including on foreign teams.
Message actions	Message actions can be only invoked by users belonging to the workspace your app is installed.
Interactive messages	Handle action invocation by users from other teams, and letting them know if an action is not permissible due to their external nature.
Unfurls	When a user on the installing workspace posts a link in the shared channel. The link should be unfurled for the entire channel unless there is a privacy concern.
RTM	Support users from other workspace in shared channels where appropriate. Message deliveries are duplicated in shared channels when installed on multiple joined workspaces due to the multiple socket connections.
Bot users 🤖	Bot users can DM all local users in the workspace they are installed in, and external users with a common shared channel.

Conversations API

Developing with channels between organizations and workspaces effectively requires using the new Web API methods we call the Conversations API.

Requesting a sandbox

Building properly for channels between workspaces and organizations requires experiencing the unique constraints and opportunities yourself.

If you don't already have access to workspaces with the proper plan level to grant access to channels between organizations, please complete the form below to request a sandbox. We'll get back to you as soon as possible.

Request a sandbox

Troubleshooting and known issues

We're still working on Slack Connect. It's likely you'll run into a bug or three.

Here's what we know about:

🚧 MPIM events tell little lies about channel types

In a multiparty direct message channel ("MPIM") with a foreign user, events like member_joined_channel and member_left_channel may dispatch an incorrect value for channel_type.

🚧 IM Object format is not yet consistent

IM formats may differ from other channel objects for a while. We're working towards making all objects the same format.

🚧 Select menus may be inconsistent

Default select menus (users_select, conversations_select, and channels_select) may display unexpected options in shared channels.

🚧 app_home_opened event isn't triggered for external members

When members from the non-host workspace access the app DM, the app_home_opened event will not be fired.

Stay tuned for future updates!